Maybe Replacing Kickoffs With A 4th & 15 Isn’t A Bad Idea

NFL – And one of the more prevalent talking points lately has centered on the dangers of kickoffs. Prior to the 2011 season, kickoffs were moved up to the 35-yard-line, drastically decreasing the number of returns attempted. If at least one NFL coach has his way, the league won’t stop there. According to TIME, Goodell recently discussed with Rick McKay, Falcons president and head of the NFL’s competition committee, a radical rule change proposed by Tampa Bay coach Greg Schiano. Instead of a kickoff, the team that scored would then take the ball on its own 30-yard line in, essentially, a 4th-and-15 situation. In other words, they could attempt to keep their offense on the field and try to pick up 15 yards, at the risk of turning the ball over on downs; or they could punt. “I don’t do things for public relations,” Goodell said. “I do things because they’re the right thing to do, because I love the game.”
It’s understandable that everybody wants to keep things the same since nostalgia and sports go together like gay men and anal-numbing lube, but Schiano’s idea isn’t that bad. Onsides kicks flat out don’t work. I’m not going to look up the percentages but I’m sure it’s somewhere between “Nope” and “Your Team Already Lost”. A 4th & 15 situation would make the ending of NFL games exponentially more exciting, raise the stakes for Fantasy players, and allow good defenses to put teams away without hoping some special teams hands guy can grab a lucky bounce. Teams would be concocting all types of trickery 15-yard plays to get that extra possession; coaches would probably dedicate a whole offensive package to it during the offseason.
Also, it’s not like 2/3 of all kickoffs aren’t touchbacks already. Part of the game was made lame by moving the ball to the 35 on the kickoff, might as well change the rules once more to increase safety AND make it exciting again.
PS – Fuck a kneeldown.

Are you fucking retarded?
I’m so fucking sick of you Mo. I hope the Jew fires your before Kwanzaa.
Most retarded idea I’ve ever heard. Goodell should be let go
Moving the ball 5 yards up on the kickoff did increase touchbacks but it didn’t take away the excitement of kickoff altogether. This idea is gay
Mo…. just go watch basketball, please.
fkn idiot,, dumbest idea since the abolishment of slavery.
Let Bob Costas decide! He obviously knows everything there has ever needed to be known!
You must be blogging this for feedback and I’m sorry to fall into your trap. But if you have a dick and balls between your legs: you don’t tolerate Goodell and this bull shit. 5 yards was bad; this is crossing the f’ing line.
I’ve read this proposed rule change 5 times today and I still have no fucking idea how it would work.
my problem with it is that on a kickoff theirs basically no chance of the kicking team regaining posession whereas with this its significantly better for no reason
unless your the jets
I wouldnt pay $.50 for this idea! The fact goodell likes it should be red flag enough
FIRST OF ALL THIS IDEA KICKS ASS.
Secondly the racism of some stoolies is downright embarrassing. Seriously do you all fuck your sisters?
@ texasrangers no, but we usually fuck your slutty, bukkake loving sister if thats any consolation
Stupid fucking idea. Stop the pussification of the NFL. We already allow transgender QBs to play (see Sanchez, Mark, he must have a vagina)
schiano, what a beauty
@mikepage12, you may have said “@ texasrangers no, but we usually fuck your slutty, bukkake loving sister if thats any consolation”
BUT
what i read is, “i’m a virgin and who can never stand up to people in real life so i act tough and vulgar in the comments section of blogs”
How do you start the game? Coin flip to see who starts with 4th and 15? Home team gets it at the 20? This is gay.
Hahahhahahahahhahahaba wetbandits is a fucking nerd
Uh uh i m m m mean what i read is that your just a big bully and are mean to people. Im the wetbandit and i wont put up with that nonsense! Im so fucking self-righteous and cool!!!
and thats why Tampa Bay sucks dick
I’m sure the 2010 Super Bowl Saints would have LOVED this rule, instead of you know…surprising everyone with an onside kick to help win the game.
every good offensive team that got up 17 points would take the 4th and 15 Every time.
You think it’s really that tough for a top offense to convert a 4th and 15 with the amount of bullshit automatic first down defensive penalties?
Imagine the pats punching one in to go up 21, then converting, to snag another drive for Brady. Then if they get a FG you think there going to be shy about going again?
What’s the worst that happens? The other team stops them and scores to bring the game back to two scores?
this idea is almost as awful as investing in Mike Vick or Andrew Bynum to be the centerpiece of your pro sports franchise
Onside kicks are successful 26% of the time: http://www.advancednflstats.com/2009/09/onside-kicks.html
This idea is beyond stupid. Say the team decides to punt, it will be from around their 20 yd line which gives the recieveing team the ball around thier own 40 or so? Not to mention punt returns can also be as dangerous as kickoff returns.
.
PS: @Texasrangers, the irony of you complaining about racism while using the word Fag in your user name is second to none.
Being honest… if they really are going to do away with the kickoff eventually, which I personally think will happen within about 5 years, this is a pretty solid direction to go in.
I’m a nerd. Mikepage12, you sound like a fourteen year old puss.
-
Racism is funny when you’re making a joke, like Dave Chapelle pointing out stereotypes through humor or Daniel Tosh pushing the envelope of what is socially acceptable. Racism isn’t funny when you’re just using it to makeup for your shitty sense of humor, like Carlos Mencia. A lot of comments fall into the Mencia category.
Your a piece of shit for using that photo for this blog maurice. Pathetic
it only won the saints a superbowl…
@mikepage12, i may be a nerd, but it doesn’t make any of what i said less true
what about giving the option to either kick off or go for it? However, I think 4th and 15 is too short. Needs to be like 4th and 25. Don’t see this ever happening, regardless.
I personally would like to see a Neil down
Shit idea, if it aint broke dont fix it. The NFL is fine the way it is. Whats the difference in danger between a punt return and a KO return? Horrific injuries can happen in any point in the game.
No idea how this works. Perhaps this is an obvious question but. where on the field does the 4th and 15/punt take place?
like if its at the 30…. can you kick a field goal? the avg punt is like 40 yards…that would be a great advantage to the receiving team… im intrigued/confused/refuse to do any real research
too confusing! lets just stick with paralyzing people on the field
But what about all the gang bangers with speed who’s sole function in life has been/is to catch the mofo ball and run like a darkly colored, more violent, more stupid version of Forest Gump?
Maybe Maurice is a fucking idiot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlv6BrrxD_4